In settling in to start Qigong, I teach a same small thing: a long, soft out-breath with a sound we call “Haaa.” We breathe in gently, let the out-breath run a little longer, and let the body settle. People notice it right away. The shoulders drop. The face softens. Something feels quieter.
You may have heard an explanation for why that works. Slow breathing, the story goes, “tones your vagus nerve,” and the proof is a number on your watch called HRV. It has been taught in yoga classes, books about dealing with stress, and breathing apps. This year, that explanation took a hard hit. The breathing didn’t.
What Changed
Early this year, thirty-nine specialists in heart, nerve, and evolutionary physiology published a review of polyvagal theory, the framework behind much of the “vagal tone” language. Their conclusion: the physiology the theory proposes doesn’t hold up against decades of evidence.
A separate group of international experts made a related recommendation about the heart-rhythm measure at the center of it. The rise and fall of heart rate with each breath has long been read as a gauge of the vagus nerve. They recommend renaming it “respiratory heart-rate variability,” precisely so people stop reading it that way. The size of that rhythm depends heavily on how you breathe: slower, deeper breaths make it bigger on their own. It is not aa gauge of the vagus nerve.
What Didn’t Change
Here is the part that is important: slow breathing with a longer out-breath calms people. That is one of the best-documented effects in this whole field, and nothing in the new work disputes it. Even the review’s authors note that the practices these ideas grew up around, including mindfulness and yoga, may bring real benefits on their own.
What’s in question is the explanation, not the experience. This experience has been noted by the ancients of many cultures. The calm you feel after five slow breaths is real. The recent wiring diagram that was supposed to explain it is what’s being redrawn– the why of that calming experience is what is being rethought, not whether there is a felt calming.
About the Number on Your Watch
If you track HRV on a watch or ring, enjoy watching it rise when you breathe slowly. That’s expected. Just hold it lightly. A bigger number during slow breathing mostly shows that you’re breathing slowly. It’s a helpful mirror of “I’m settling,” not a grade on your nervous system, swings when you exert yourself or rest are normal, and day-to-day swings are normal.
Why I Find This Good News
So in our class materials, I changed the sentence, not the practice. Instead of “slow breathing tones your vagus,” I now say: slow breathing settles the body, and it also changes a heart-rate rhythm. Instead of naming a nerve circuit, I name the experience: steadier, softer, more open.
Qigong never depended on that circuit diagram in the first place. Its own language — qi, the Dan Tian, the soft “Haaa” — was always openly figurative, a way of pointing at what we feel and what works, rather than a claim about wiring. That’s one reason the practice can survive a change in the science without changing at all.
The Other Side
Defenders of polyvagal theory, including its originator, argue that the critique targets a simplified version of the theory, and that its clinical usefulness is a separate question from its physiology. The reviewers themselves didn’t propose a replacement explanation. So the honest summary is strong expert doubt about one mechanism, and no settled alternative yet.
I’m comfortable holding that open. In our classes we call this openness Mindful Not Knowing: we can say with confidence that the practice calms and steadies, and say just as honestly that we don’t yet know exactly why. Not knowing is part of what keeps the practice interesting.
Try it today: five slow breaths
Sit or stand, whichever is comfortable.
1. Breathe in gently through the nose, letting the belly soften and rise.
2. Breathe out slowly with a soft “Haaa,” a little longer than the in-breath.
3. Repeat five times.
4. Notice how you feel, not what a device says.
Keep it easy and comfortable, never more than about 70% of your effort. If you feel lightheaded, return to your normal breath.
What we know, and what stays open. Slow breathing with a longer out-breath reliably helps the body shift toward calm, and regular Qigong practice supports balance, stress relief, and overall well-being. What stays open is the exact mechanism. The once-popular vagal explanation is now under serious doubt, and nothing has replaced it yet.
Next week: One Territory, Many Maps. If the science can redraw its explanation while the breath stays the same, how should we hold explanations at all? Next week: how I keep traditional Chinese medicine and modern science side by side, without asking either to be the whole story.
Practice with us
Free weekly class: Wednesdays, 10 AM, University Church, 5655 S. University Ave., Chicago.
Classes at Bodhi & Sage Wellness Community, 1525 E. 55th St., 3rd Floor, Chicago: schedule and registration coming soon.
Nothing in this post constitutes medical advice. It is offered for educational and wellness purposes only. Please consult a qualified healthcare provider before beginning any movement, breathing, or meditation practice.
Curated and directed by C. Havens · Researched and drafted by Claude (Anthropic), under Charlie’s direction.



